No announcement yet.

The Zealotry of The Doctor


  • The Zealotry of The Doctor

    Have you ever heard of the Zeal of the Convert? This phrase comes from the perception that converts to a new religion are frequently more fiercely devout than those who were born into it. Of course, not all converts are aggressive zealots – I wouldn’t even say most of them are. Despite the negative implications of this stereotype, l believe it is logical and perfectly understandable that someone who reached an epiphany about their own existence would be very excited about their new awareness and passionate about traveling down the path they just discovered. They might even try to convince you to go with them!

    This phenomenon isn’t limited to religion. You can find examples of it among people of all kinds wherever someone adopts a new idea or way of thinking. There’s the ex-smoker who becomes fiercely anti-smoking or the new vegetarian that proselytizes about their food choices – no matter what way of thinking you are talking about, it seems like you can find examples of new converts that are vigorous in their zeal.

    Now what does all of this have to do with Doctor Who?

    The First Doctor, Barbara, Ian, and SusanThe quick and dirty (and pertinent) about Doctor Who – it was and is a British science fiction serial program that ran for 26 seasons until it was cancelled by the BBC in 1989, only to be revived as a television movie in 1996, and more successfully resurrected in 2005. This new Doctor Who is still airing today, and while the show remains a cultural icon in Great Britain, it has earned a level of popularity in the United States that the classic series never achieved. If you’ve read this far, I’ll bet you already knew all of that.

    I have no idea about numbers, but I think it is safe to say that a large portion of fans of the new Doctor Who have never seen an episode of the classic series. They are available on streaming services, but twenty-six seasons with dozens of missing episodes is a daunting task, especially when the production values of the classic series were very different from those in the new. The truth is: many American fans are in the dark about the Doctor’s life and personality prior to Christopher Eccleston’s Ninth Doctor.

    This is important because the Doctor today is characterized by his extreme humanity. This alien, the Doctor, embodies the pinnacle heroic human ideal. He is selfless, wants to preserve life at all costs, stands up for the downtrodden, despises ignorance and cherishes wonderment. He is compassionate and empathetic, in his own alien way. His devotion to these traits could almost be described as fanatical. He’s a zealot. And, whether you realize it or not – he is a convert. Many of today’s fans aren’t familiar with the character traits of the earlier incarnations of the Doctor, and don’t realize that we didn’t start seeing this kind of ultra-humanity until he was a more than a few incarnations in. If you haven't watched any Classic Doctor Who, you may be shocked at the personality of the Doctor you see.

    Those of you who have watched Classic Doctor Who, particularly episodes of the very first serial will recall a very different Doctor. Originally, the First Doctor was very similar in personality to what we saw from other Time Lords later in the series. He was arrogant and dismissive, distrustful of the inferior humans. He was a rude elitist who was willing to kill to save his own neck. He saw humans as inferior and did not shy away from making this opinion known. This was a Doctor who delighted in kidnapping two unsuspecting humans and taking them away from their native time just to teach them a lesson for being so impertinent. This Doctor tried to take a pacifist race and make them go to war against a superior warlike enemy – all to make up for one of his own dishonest schemes gone wrong. This was a typical Time Lord, not the paragon of humanity we have come to know in the new series.

    If the Doctor is a convert to humanity, his first two human companions – Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright – were his proselytizers. If you look at their actions in An Unearthly Child, you will find a pair of teachers who are very concerned about one of their students (the Doctor’s granddaughter, Susan Foreman). They visit her “home,” only to find that her address on file is a junkyard. Unable to find Susan, they eventually meet the Doctor – who to them appeared to be a strange and evasive old man who could be a danger to Susan. And when they discover that Susan herself is hiding in what seems to them to be a small Police Box? What else would any decent human do but force themselves into the situation, refuse to accept the Doctor’s deceptive and dismissive explanations, and try to protect one of their charges? In the Doctor’s first real experience with humans, he was the villain, and ended up the victim of that sort of aggressive compassion that eventually came to define him.

    Doctor: Murderer?Over the next several stories, Ian and Barbara began to mold the Doctor. Their early relationship was very confrontational: after all, the Doctor had taken them from their home against their will, placing them in danger time and time again. Despite their frustrations, despite being exposed to a fantastic reality they never-before imagined, they held on to what made them decent human beings and insisted that the Doctor behave the same way. They chided him for his lack of compassion, berated him for his unwillingness to put others before himself. They treated him with justifiable suspicion and refused to let him out of their sight – after all, he was perfectly willing to abandon them if it meant he could safely escape a situation with Susan. One particularly impactful moment came when Ian had to stop the Doctor from murdering a wounded caveman with a rock, all because Ian and Barbara’s insisted that they keep their enemy from dying. That act was costing them their opportunity to escape. Despite all the universe threw at them (including the Doctor), Ian and Barbara remained examples of honor and compassion, and showed the Doctor that their way worked.

    Barbara and Ian forced the Doctor to behave with decency, and eventually he started to come around. They prevented him from being truly evil through aggressive supervision, and as he continued to travel with them, he eventually grew to accept and love them, behaving like a decent human being would. His demeanor became softer – he was less the grouchy alien and became more the lovable grandpa. Ian and Barbara fought against him less, because he stopped giving them reasons too. He was learning to behave, learning to embrace humanity.

    There was still conflict to him, but he slowly learned to cope with those scenarios where human morality could not apply to the wider universe of time travel. In The Aztecs he remained firm in his opposition to Barbara’s attempts to change history, yet sympathized with her rationale and remained compassionate when she eventually was forced to admit he was right. In The Sensorites, we see the first glimpses of him as the Protector of Humanity when he tries to save Captain Maitland and his crew from the telepathic Sensorites.

    The Doctor has continued to evolve throughout his different incarnations, but in his very first we see how he transitioned from a Time Lord view on morality to something that a human might find admirable. He is still a long way from The Oncoming Storm that began with the Ninth Doctor at this point, but his faith was only growing. Today, more than fifty years after we first see William Hartnell’s Doctor, he’s finally become a Zealot in the church of humanity – and this is the Doctor that most American fans know and love today.

    I wonder if she will continue to be in the coming season?


    Doctor Who Season 1
    • An Unearthly Child (Episodes 1-4)
    • The Daleks (Episodes 5-11)
    • The Aztecs (Episodes 27-30)

    • Blake M. Petit
      Blake M. Petit commented
      Editing a comment
      Admittedly, I haven't seen a lot of Classic Who, but I like this interpretation of the character. It even fits in a bit with some of the ways the Tennant through Capaldi Doctors struggled to find themselves. Capaldi in particular seemed compelled to define himself.

    • Craig Reade
      Craig Reade commented
      Editing a comment
      Capaldi did a really good job bring the "alien" back to the character. Matt Smith was ok at this, but he ended up being just a little awkward, as opposed to alien.

      I think that is one thing I really liked about the Classic Series more than the Modern - the evolving Doctor. Sure, we get different base personalities, but at the end of the day, all of the stories end up being the crusading Doctor saving humanity. Watching the Doctor evolve from the crotchety, selfish First Doctor to the highly manipulative Seventh is a lot of fun. Not that it wasn't hard to get caught up, but I found it worth it.
    You must register in order to comment!

What Do You Think?


Latest Articles


  • In Which I Become a Screenwriter
    A friend of mine and I were talking one day, while filming the teaser for Spider (a short film based on my short story). She said “Our next movie should be about killer tampons.”

    “Hell yes it should,” I said.

    I was not serious.

    But the more we discussed it, and the more I thought about it, the more it seemed like a great idea. I’d never written a screenplay before, and had no idea how to do it, but goddammit, the world needs this movie. What better way to test my comedic horror skills than by creating this piece of ridiculousness?

    And so, while on a writers retreat, I wrote the entire screenplay. In three days. And you guys, it was one of the funnest things I’ve ever done. Writing a screenplay is all the best parts of writing a novel, with none of the boring tedious parts. It’s all action and dialogue! THAT’S ALL IT IS.

    In my screenplay, titled Red Wings, a woman is bitten by a bat, and then discovers that...
    02-28-2019, 06:55 PM
  • The Book is NOT Better: A Series of Unfortunate Events
    Blake M. Petit
    A friend and fellow teacher at my school has a sign in her room that reads “The book is ALWAYS better.” It’s an amusing sign that speaks volumes about her personality, and her former students often quote it when they enter my classroom a year later. However, as much fun as it is, I don’t think that sign is accurate. Oh, to be sure, the book is USUALLY better. But the sign doesn’t say “usually,” it says “always,” a word which here means “in perpetuity and without exception throughout the universe.” The problem with an absolute statement such as this one is that even a single exception can invalidate it. The film version of Jaws, compared to the original novel, is more taught, has greater suspense, and does away with that rubbish subplot about Hooper having an affair with Brody’s wife. The ending of the film The Mist concludes things with a tone so bleak and hopeless that Stephen King even said he’d wished he thought of it himself. And having finally binged the third and final season of...
    01-14-2019, 07:18 PM
  • How the Movies Saved Christmas
    Blake M. Petit
    Christmas, my friends, is under attack. I’m not talking about some vague conspiracy, the encroachment of “Happy Holidays” into our lexicon, or red cups at Starbucks. No, I’m talking about the clear and present danger of evil corporations, extraterrestrial invaders, ancient curses, and Martin Short. Every year, it seems, there is some terrible calamity that faces the holiday season, and it’s up to somebody from our favorite movies and television specials to step up and save the day.

    Today, we’re going to rank ten movies and TV specials in which a hero rises to the occasion and saves Christmas. Now keep in mind, saving Christmas is a delicate operation. Not just anybody can do it, and not every disaster really qualifies. There are hundreds of stories in which Christmas is going to suck for our protagonists until some miracle makes them merry after all. You won’t find those stories here. In order to qualify as “saving Christmas,” the holiday has to be in danger for people outside...
    12-03-2018, 06:49 PM
  • DC Universe: Early Impressions
    Blake M. Petit
    It’s been a couple of weeks now since DC Universe, the new online streaming service, was launched. I’ve spent a good bit of time playing with it, and I know some people wanted to hear my thoughts, so I’m going to give you guys a quick rundown on the three major components of the service, going from the least satisfying to the most.

    First off, the movies. The movie selection is fairly small -- the Christopher Reeve Superman movies, the first two Christopher Nolan Batman movies, several of the animated films. Part of the issue here may be one of availability -- I have no idea who currently has the streaming rights to, for example, the two Swamp Thing movies, so it’s possible that DC couldn’t offer those even if they wanted to. But there are other things that they definitely DO have that aren’t there -- the Burton/Schumacher Batman movies, for example, were put on the site for two weeks following “Batman Day” on September 15, but were then removed on October 1. Why? They...
    10-03-2018, 02:00 PM
  • The Superhero Watch: X-Men Movies United (Part 2)
    Blake M. Petit
    In the beginning, there were Stan and Jack, and yea, they begat the children of the atom. And yea, it was good, And as always seems to happen with good things, eventually they made some movies out of them. In part one of this two-part installment of The Superhero Watch, we looked at the six movies (so far) that make up the main X-Men movie franchise. Today, in part two, we're looking at the three solo Wolverine films, the two adventures of Deadpool, and we glance ahead at the future of the 20th Century Fox X-Men universe once it moves over to its new overlords at the Walt Disney Global Media Consolidation Phalanx and Tiki Bar. And don't forget to read the previous installments focusing on the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the Spider-Man franchise, and the Superman films. And if you want to keep track of my progress in-between articles, there’s a Letterboxd list just for that purpose.

    The Wolverine Trilogy: X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009), The Wolverine (2013), Logan (2017)....
    09-12-2018, 04:13 PM
  • The Superhero Watch: X-Men Movies United (Part 1)
    Blake M. Petit
    Before the MCU, before Spider-Man on the screen, and well after Howard the Duck, there was a different sort of Marvel Movie Universe. It wasn’t Marvel’s first hit -- that honor belongs to Blade-- but it was the series that redefined the superhero movie. In many ways, I don’t think the current dominance of superhero movies would exist if it weren’t for 20th Century Fox’s X-Men franchise. Today in the Superhero Rewatch Project (you’ll notice I dropped the “2018” -- I’ve resigned myself that there’s no way in hell I’ll finish this before the end of the year), we’re going to look at the eleven films that make up that universe thus far. And of course, feel free to read the previous installments focusing on the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the Spider-Man franchise, and the Superman films. And if you want to keep track of my progress in-between articles, there’s a Letterboxd list just for that purpose.

    The story of the X-Men films to date is the story of three trilogies, plus Deadpool....
    09-11-2018, 03:25 PM